Showing posts with label Neil DeGrasse Tyson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Neil DeGrasse Tyson. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 11, 2017

Bill Nye: Science Guy

Prejudicial Confession: I have known William Nye for...what?...35 years (Lordy...tick, tick, tick). A professional encounter doing radio ads for a computer store and a mutual friendship led me to working in the post-sound department for "Disney Presents 'Bill Nye the Science Guy'" for the first couple of seasons (a marathoning 65 episodes). Best job I ever had. So, I am, of course, predisposed to like this film. Just a warning.

Unde-NYE-a-BILL
or
The Man in the Arena (Fit to be Bow-Tied)

I first became aware of this enterprise when I found myself in the middle of filming it. It was at a party for the 20th Anniversary of the production of "Bill Nye the Science Guy" and the titular host was being followed by a film crew dutifully recording our shenanigans. I ducked the cameras, but I was curious to see how the resulting film turned out.

The result, Bill Nye: Science Guy, is out now and making the film festival circuit before debuting next year on PBS' "POV" docu-series and it's probably never more timely than now. Bill's made quite a career for himself as a talking head on the news channels for any scientific subject from Global Warming (or "Climate Change" if you can't get your mind around why it would actually snow as a result) to "AI" (a lot of people are worried about the growth of it—I worry about the shrinking of natural intelligence) to whatever "science-y thing" happens that needs somebody to explain it simply and entertainingly. Bill's good at that. A lot of that has to do with an infectious curiosity and an on-camera enthusiasm that can, frankly, be alarming. Bill loves the tech, the arcana, and the proof, and he loves to demonstrate it with a brio that would intimidate Colin Clive.
These qualities made Bill a hero for a couple generations of kids bored by the statistics of science class...it at least kept them awake. That show (as he admits in the film) "nearly killed me." And the past couple decades he's been showing up on the tube in his "expert" mode and some television shows ("The Big Bang Theory," of course and "Numb3rs"—which its creators say was partially inspired by the "Science Guy" show). But, he's also expanded his range, becoming CEO of Carl Sagan's Planetary Society, writing a series of books (that are personal, informative, and funny), and doing good work—stumping for funding education, and being a very vocal advocate for the recognition of climate change, and against the forces of dogma and superstition. That has also made him a lot of enemies...like half-Governor Sarah Palin who decried that he was "just an actor on a kids show"* (No, half-Governor, you're thinking of Paul Zaloom—he's BIG in Latin America!) and any other person whose future doesn't extend any further than the next fiscal year of their financial statement.

The latter is the subject of Bill Nye: Science Guy following Bill (with extraordinary access, I thought) as he schleps around the country making personal appearances, posing for endless selfies—"you DO suffer from 'selfie fatigue'" he offers at one point—and doing the work, public and private, that intrigues him, holding up a single Bunsen burner of Science alight in the face of an encroaching Dark Age of fake news, psuedo-science and a knee-jerk suspicion of facts in the preference of urban legend.
 
Media made Bill a star, but there's just as much media—well-funded media—putting out a lot of crap (remember when The Discovery Channel was about REAL stuff?) and the Science Guy is Hans-Brinker-in-a-lab-coat trying to stem the tide. BN:SG watches fairly dispassionately as Nye passionately argues and counter-argues against claims that he feels are not only wrong-headed, but dangerous. And Bottom-line-feeders don't like that, as much as magicians and charlatans don't like The Amazing Randi.
High School Bill
The film skips along mostly hovering around Bill's current day-job at the Planetary Society (where he's overseeing his old astronomy professor Carl Sagan's dream of "a solar sail"), his speaking engagements, and his quest to "evangelize" the dangers of climate change, but also delves into his past as young nerd to Boeing engineer to comedy writer for Seattle's comedy show "Almost Live!" (director Steve Wilson weighs in) to the formation of "The Science Guy" persona (a last-minute skit idea when a scheduled guest cancelled) to the Disney/PBS Show (with interviews with co-creators Jim McKenna, Erren Gottlieb and writer/science researcher Ian G. Saunders—looking good, kids!) to his new roles, complemented with interviews with Neil DeGrasse Tyson and Ann Druyan. He's also committed to trying to "tilt" the windmills of climate change deniers and entrepreneurial anti-evolutionists (who seem to have learned their history by studying "The Flintstones"—"eh, it's a living..."), but one gets the impression that he always gets drowned out by the sound of the change in their pockets.
Bill Parson's Sheldon, Bill, Bob Newhart's Prof. Proton, and Johnny Galecki's Leonard
on "The Big Bang Theory"

The quixotic aspect of Nye is the most fascinating (although some of the glimpses of family history which have an underlying spark in Nye's pursuits, that he is unafraid to examine and share, are also raw and inspiring), as he continually meets with, and prods, counters, and challenges proponents of the more profitable views of the issues. It is a lonely task that puts him in the arena for public scrutiny by any yay-hoo with a private agenda (or web-site) and the idle riskless scorn of the trolling sycophants who have the mob mentality of the patrons of the Roman Coliseum. You have to admire him for that.
And you have to admire him for the final answer he gave in the well-known debate with the gent who challenged him to a debate on evolution and the 6,000 year old Earth theory. When asked if there was anything that might change their minds, the fellow who accused Nye and others of making science "a religion" had his karma run over his dogma by saying "As a Christian, nothing would change my mind." When Nye answered, he said it with one word: "Evidence." Science and its study is about asking questions, rather than acting like you know all the answers.

*** Bill's sustained double-take on Ms. Palin's statement is one of the moments in the film that made me laugh out loud. Her contention that "I know as much about science as him" is as accurate as "I can see Russia from my house!" but is emblematic of what is a human trait—people who are actually not expert at something think they're better at it than they are—think of the guy who tail-gates you at 60 mph; he thinks he knows driving but knows nothing about physics, or is so sure of his driving skills and his brakes that he thinks he can avoid the inevitable smash-up that will occur if there is a momentary change in driving speed. It seems we have gone from "Not knowing what you don't know" to "Not caring about what you don't know" to "being proud of what you don't know." Nobody should be PROUD of their ignorance. 

Two guys playing to the camera: The one on the left being fulsome.
The guy on the right not needing to be.

Thursday, September 15, 2016

For the Love of Spock

The Needs of the One
or
I Will Fight Nimoy Forever

“After a time, you may find that having is not so pleasing a thing, after all, as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true.”
"Amok Time" Star Trek Season Two, Episode 1

When there was a survey of what Washington residents "googled" the most in the year 2015, the number one entry was "Leonard Nimoy." Trace William Cowen had this to say about it at Complex.com: "Washington wisely concentrated its 2015 Googling efforts toward the late actor Leonard Nimoy, a commendable decision by any measurement, but certainly made more remarkable by the fact that their neighbors seemed far more concerned with wolves and vaccines."

The death of Leonard Nimoy, who was, after all, 83, caused far more of a seismic-shift than I might have realized. Obama commented on it, for crying out loud, and I couldn't turn on the radio without hearing regrets, sympathies, and commentaries on "what Spock meant to me," many of which focused on "otherness" and split-parentage and of the better qualities of our nature.

The guy played an alien with pointed ears, but Spock was more than that, as embodied and realized by Nimoy. So much of what is termed "Vulcan" (can I say that without Paul Allen hitting me with a lawsuit?)—in its heritage, history, sociology—emerged from the last-second improvisations and ideas from Nimoy, that no actor can play a person of that fictional race without going back to "the Nimoy template." What other acting role can say that? So much of the Vulcan trademarks that emerged from Nimoy's portrayal, like the stoicism, the blankness that could be punctuated and energized by the mere raising of an eyebrow—the restraint, most of all (and it IS active, not passive)—but also the "salute," the finger-stuff, "the nerve-pinch," all stuff Nimoy created on-set to set Spock apart and cleave him to the mostly non-violent alien who didn't lie, didn't bluff (but could intellectualize around it, very precisely), devoting himself to logic and favoring his Vulcan heritaghe over his Earth heritage. While Shatner's Captain Kirk was emoting (with a capital "E") and...gesticulating...around the paper mache boulders and faux-future-furniture, Nimoy found that he could attract eyes with stillness no matter how red in the face the captain got. No other alien race of the "Star Trek" ilk feels so complete, not even the much-focused-on Klingon's of the later shows.
My only memory of Nimoy was a story an old boss of mine told me about Nimoy in his scuffling days when he was working at a small California TV station as a crew-member and when the boss told him to move something, he grinned and said "But, Ozzie! I'm a song-and-dance man!" "Just...move the desk, willya Lenny?"

Back in those early days between sporadic guest shots on television, he was working odd-jobs, trying to make ends meet for his family of four. That same work ethic would apply when "Star Trek" hit big and he could use his name to ensure sales of record albums, poetry and photography collections, making him a 'brand," that would generate income. After "Star Wars" came out, paying its stars to use their likenesses on merchandising, he sued Paramount for a decade of unauthorized usage, winning a settlement from them after holding out appearing in Star Trek: The Motion Picture. He parlayed that into a directing career that saw two of his movies be the top-draws for the Christmas seasons of 1986 and 1987. He was a savvy businessman and craftsman, professionally.
Adam Nimoy and father Leonard on the set of "Star Trek."
Before he died in 2015, he'd already agreed to help his son, Adam*, do a movie about Spock for the series' 50th anniversary, no doubt not suspecting it would turn into a memorial. The resulting documentary, For the Love of Spock, hitting theaters and streaming sites simultaneously, is something of a mixed bag. It is at its best, when actually examining Nimoy's life and the "Spock mystique," with archival footage and interviews with Spock grokkers. 
Father and son on the set of "Star Trek: The Next Generation."
It is at its worst and most self-indulgent when the director inserts himself into the narrative, which happens more frequently as the movie goes along. It would be impossible for some of this not to come up—the director is the son, and seems to have inherited his father's addictive tendencies, struggling with drink and drugs, and wondering where he fits in with competition from an adoring public. He has suffered tragedy himself, which is touched on briefly in the film. 

It's a bit scatter-shot, wandering from subject to subject and focus to focus until Adam's struggles with coming to terms with his father seems to become the sole focus. It's his movie. He can do what he wants. And his father died during production. Public mourning is to be expected.

But, some of that time could have been filled with expansion. "Star Trek" is a phenomenon in The States, yes. But, one thing that typifies the series and Spock and Nimoy's interpretation of him is the sense of inclusion, of universality—is there any place in the world, any group, any nation, any fans besides the U.S. that might have been included to give the thing a bit more richness, a bit more perspective, a bit more reach? Was it just the United States and geek-dom that was touched by Nimoy, Spock, and his message?

I think not. And the film does a bit of a disservice in not even approaching that subject. It makes it all a bit narrow-minded, as if, yes, the message has been heard, but not really sunk-in, and as if the subject matter of the personal is more important than the perspective. Nimoy had more than an effect on his son, he affected the world and that is given short-shrift. That's a pity. And a lost opportunity.



* The two had already collaborated on an episode of the latter day version of "The Outer Limits," remaking an episode from the original sharing the name and some concepts of Isaac Asimov's "I, Robot."