Both Sides Now
Pollack was not "gifted" in the way that I interpreted the word for the role, no, but damned good...and a very good student And intelligent, which was conveyed through his films and their subject matters. They were committed and with issues in the back of them that made you think, long after the film's images had faded from your retinas: The nature of truth in Absence of Malice (which, was a counter-argument to his thriller Three Days of the Condor); the idea of ownership and position in (of all things) Out of Africa; culture clashes—in OoA, Havana, Jeremiah Johnson, The Yakuza; gender roles, and the yoke of women in Tootsie; and the randomness and fragility of love in The Way We Were, Bobby Deerfield, Sabrina, Random Hearts—most of his films, really. Romance had to have roadblocks, some insurmountable, in Pollack's films, but they were more fueled by hope than by commitment. One got the impression no one dared "work" in a relationship in Pollack's movies.
He was at his best without a sure track, and his best films—Jeremiah Johnson, Tootsie, and Out of Africa—seemed to find their hearts in the editing room, more than in the direction.
"That's really where the film gets made. I'm not good at editing while I'm shooting. They're two different processes to me, and I can't quite discipline my brain to do both of them at the same time. While I'm shooting, I'm searching for something. Then, in the editing, it becomes like sculpting. Editing is the process I enjoy the most. It's the one time when you're alone and you don't have to go through an army of 200 people to get what you want. On the set, I have to go through a cinematographer, a gaffer, a production designer and use the right lens, the right camera movement, the right lighting, the right clothes, and so many specific practical disciplines to translate my subconscious wishes. What you want to say to everyone is: 'Can't you just reach into my brain and do what it is that I'm daydreaming?' When you're editing, you're in a dark room, you can try anything you want and it's instantaneous."
The Scalphunters (1968) Fur-trapper Joe Bass (Burt Lancaster) has just spent a winter getting pelts and, just on his way to sell them, he gets bushwhacked by Kiowas, who take the furs and leave him with Joseph Lee (Ossie Davis), an educated runaway slave. Following the bandits, the two see the group wiped out by a band of scalphunters, who turn in the hair for reward money, the "dirtiest, rottenest trade that ever turned a dollar." They're led by Jim Howie (Telly Savalas), a low-down snake in the grass, who has a soft spot for madam Kate (Shelley Winters) with her traveling band of whores. Now that they have the pelts, they're making their murderous way to Mexico, but Bass and Lee doggedly follow them, plotting, changing sides, and generally making nuisances of themselves. A whimsical western with murderous background, The Scalphunters doesn't have much to say about race relations (which was its intention for the times), and there's not much depth here—the scalphunters, other than Howie, are characterless cyphers as much as the Natives are. Some of Pollack's set-ups are good. Some are just strange, but Lancaster still has the best teeth in the West, and it's always fun to watch Davis, who keeps you guessing throughout the entire picture.
Castle Keep (1969) During WWII in the Ardennes "eight walking wounded misfits of the American Army walked into a castle in Belgium." The castle is Maldorais and the troop—featuring Patrick O'Neal, Scott Wilson, Peter Falk, Tony Bill, Michael Conrad, James Patterson, and Al Freeman Jr. is led by Col. Falconer (Burt Lancaster, sporting an eye-patch). With the cautious permission of the Count (Jean-Pierre Aumont), the men are given permission to bivouac there—and, more surprisingly, he ignores the fact that his wife (Astrid Heeren) begins an affair with Falconer. The castle is a marvel of architecture and houses all manner of classic artwork, but it's just a strategic point on a map; there's every indication that the Germans will be marching through (and were probably previously staying there as well). While Falconer prepares and beds the Countess, and O'Neal's Capt. Beckman frets about the art, the other men spend time at the local brothel and Falk's Sgt. Rossi, a baker back home, takes up with the local baker's widow. It's one of those "war-as-myth" movies, where the most realistic thing is the carnage put on-screen, but there's no sense of strategy or coordination with any other part of the war effort. It's just "hold the castle" while the men crack wise in writerly sorts of ways—"This whole place has an ineffable, dream-like quality" (which sounds like description from William Eastlake's 1965 book, not dialogue). Oh, and it's another one of those 1960's movies that displays that a Volkswagon "beetle" floats. One might think the movie was an "anti-war" movie if it didn't take such care blowing things up. The castle, by the way, was made of styrofoam and the film has a similar feel of unreality.
They Shoot Horses, Don't They? (1969) Yowza! Horace McCoy's distillation of The American Dream into a Depression-era dance marathon—"The Dance of Destiny"—makes a compelling, focused film (hard to believe that it was originally going to be a collaboration between Harold Lloyd and Charlie Chaplin!) that extrapolates the fates of down-on-their-luck couples all trying to land the "Big Prize" of $150,000 in silver dollars by outlasting every other contestant, who are eliminated by exhaustion, physical injury, and even death. It's Survival of the Fittest...or, at least, the stubbornest. The stubbornest is Gloria (Jane Fonda, never better, never less sentimental), who is the definition of a hard-luck kid, who has a stranger named Robert (Michael Sarrazin) thrust on her as a last-minute partner in the marathon. But, Gloria is determined to win and Robert just as determined to get her there. Also, competing are a married couple (Bruce Dern and Bonnie Bedelia), an actress seeking the limelight (Susannah York) and a WWI Naval veteran (Red Buttons—amazing!), who is quite a capable dancer...in a sprint.
Redford is amazing in this—he's always at his best when not talking—and the film plays out as travelogue, tone-poem, and song-story that never feels forced or out of step. Supposedly the picture came together in an extensive editing phase and is one of those movies that feels iconic and (ironically) blazing new trails in form—it clearly had influence on Eastwood when he took over The Outlaw Josey Wales. Redford and Pollack disagreed on how the movie should end, but manage to reach a coda that makes its own peace without telling the end of the story.*
The Way We Were (1973) Arthur Laurents' soap opera about political and personality opposites attracting is hardly repellent. But, it ain't great, either (even the author didn't like the finished film with what Pollack had done with it—but then, some of the typewriters the film passed through belonged to Dalton Trumbo, Herb Gardner, Paddy Chayefsky, and Francis Ford Coppola so he might have been a bit biased). One of the first pictures to feature the Hollywood Blacklist as a subject, The Way We Were tells the story of Katie Morosky (Barbra Streisand), a campus radical who meets a wasp-ish under-achiever Hubbell Gardiner (Redford in his third film with Pollack), their subsequent relationship after the war, and their tensions during the 1950's. It is a film killed by compromise—a lot of the politics is left out (although it probably seems like too much for some) in favor of a love story that works only due to the chemistry of the two leads (which, in itself, is something of a miracle) and can be summed up by "she loves the way he looks and he loves the way she looks at him."
And "that" song. But, even then, some of the editorial choices are, frankly, jarring—honestly, weren't you a little thrown by the break-up scene?
Still, like some past romances, folks choose to remember only the good parts, which is why it is ranked number six on AFI's top 100 romantic movies. The Oscars it won were for Best Score and for "that song."

Three Days of the Condor (1975) Redford (Pollack film #4) plays Joe Turner, a CIA researcher in the "book section," who comes back from lunch to find that his co-workers have been murdered. He contacts CIA HQ and is told to come in for his safety. But at that meeting, he is nearly killed, and he goes into hiding to find out who set up the hits and why, and without anyone he can trust. The film came out post-Watergate, but was in production when that conspiracy went down, so there are minor influences owing to the tenor of the times ("Boy, what is it with you people? You think not getting caught in a lie is the same thing as telling the truth?" is a line that haunts). Where the film is prophetic is in its main root cause—oil—and the CIA's capacity for conducting operations inside the boundaries of the U.S. In the 20/20 of hindsight, one of the most unusual things is Turner's abduction, use, and eventual seduction of a total stranger (Faye Dunaway) to help him with his plans, including the kidnapping of his bureau chief (Cliff Robertson). That seems "formula" for a thriller in the 40's (studio demand for a love interest being the motivation), but it feels forced and strange and more than a little criminal these days. It also makes Dunaway's character seem a bit crazy. I mean, Redford is handsome and all, but, come on...
A competent thriller, but what I remember fondly is Turner's conversation with the puckishly ironic assassin, Joubert (Max von Sydow) who suggests that to stay in hiding, he should become an assassin himself, as he seems to have "skills."
![]() |
von Sydow's rather happy assassin |
Bobby Deerfield (1977) An adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque's "Heaven Has No Favorites" but moved from its original 1948 setting to the 1970's. Francois Truffaut was originally slated to direct, but Pollack was given the script by actor Dabney Colman (with the suggestion that Gene Hackman star). Catherine Deneuve actively pursued the role of Lillian, the "hot-chick-born-yesterday" that Deerfield meets at a sanatorium when he goes to visit a fellow race-driver who's been injured in an accident that haunts him. Al Pacino, hot after The Godfather, Serpico, and Dog Day Afternoon, plays the emotionally-distant title character whom the mysterious woman he becomes obsessed with describes as "driving around in circles." Apt. Although, that accident has been on his mind...a lot...and won't drive again until he finds the answer. Alvin Sargent, the screenwriter, has echoes of his adaptation of The Sterile Cukoo to it and that would be fine if the two leads had a more charming touch with comedy. But, they don't, no matter how much composer Dave Grusin tries to overlay a "light touch" with his score. The fact is, the movie doesn't know whether to be a drama or a comedy from one moment to the next and the result is disorienting, leaving the audience as perplexed as Deerfield, an American in Europe, is. Like the running gag of Deerfield not understanding any language, it just doesn't translate.
The Electric Horseman (1979) Redford (movie #5 with Pollack) was hot and Fonda (movie #2 with Pollack) was trying to rehabilitate her career after her political activities in the '70's. They'd starred together in the movie version of Barefoot in the Park (and The Chase, too, as I recall), so it's a bit like "old-home week" with the two's previously displayed chemistry still on-display and repeatable, although Fonda could no longer be believed as a coquettish scatter-brain and Redford the blond pretty-boy (roles which I'm sure they both loathed).

Redford plays Sonny Steele, former rodeo champ, who's making ends meet by being a spokesman for the "Ranch" cereal company, riding around on a city-tour, currently in Vegas, where the idea is for him to show up on horseback on-stage in an electrified suit. To do this, they've had to drug the horse into practically catatonia, which awakens the last vestige of integrity in Sonny and he rustles the horse to release it into the nearby desert—hopefully after it snaps out of the drugs. Parallel stories about being free and "true to your roots" blah blah blah...Fonda plays a reporter who's following the story and is the obligatory love interest. It was the first movie Willie Nelson appeared in, and the second for crusty Wilford Brimley—both veterans of just about everything but movie-acting.
The Electric Horseman is so incongruously inoffensive, simultaneously cashing in on the "cowboy-bar" phase the country troughed into in the late 70's (probably as an answer to "disco" and its excesses—this time it was mechanical bulls and oxycontin) while railing against corporate appropriation of "self" and "genuineness," put out by, not one, but two movie-making corporate entities while promoting Vegas at the same time holding it up for ridicule. The movie is more than a little smug and self-satisfied.
Absence of Malice (1981) A Miami reporter (Sally Field) gets wind of a story from confidential sources about suspicions around the death of a union rep and runs with it, thinking she's scored a big scoop. Turns out the story is a fishing expedition from an over-zealous prosecutor (a hyper Bob Balaban) who thinks that Michael Gallagher (Paul Newman), a liquor wholesaler whose father was a prominent mobster, had something to do with the rep's disappearance. The front-page story throws an unwanted spotlight on Gallagher and his business and, facing financial ruin, he decides to play offense by doing some double-dealing of his own. If a prosecutor can get away with planting a story, why can't he?
Tootsie (1982) Tootsie did not start out as a Sydney Pollack film. It was a project that Dustin Hoffman was fostering based on a play called "Would I Lie to You?" by Don McGuire and controlled by producer Charles Evans, who had become aware of the property from Buddy Hackett, who wanted to play the talent agent in the story. Dick Richards was to direct and worked on a screenplay with Evans and Robert Kaufman. Richards left and took over producing chores, instead. The screenplay went through many hands for tinkering—Larry Gelbart did a full re-write and such hands as Elaine May, Barry Levinson and Murray Schisgal put their fingerprints on it—and Hal Ashby was hired to direct. An extended post-production on another picture took Ashby away and that's when it fell to Pollack, who, after being badgered by Hoffman, took the role of his agent—after not having acted in almost two decades.
Out of Africa (1985) Pollack's Best Picture winner. And possibly his best film, as well.
![]() |
"I had a farm in Africa...at the foot of Ngong hills" |
Havana (1990) Redford's seventh (and last) movie with Pollack features him as Jack Weil, a wheeler-dealer American in Cuba with the looming revolution on everybody's mind. He's always the smartest guy in the room and can read anybody and knows the score before the police can find out. He's a professional gambler, a pick-pocket, and—according to Bobby Durán (Lena Olin), who is connected to the rebels and utilizes him to smuggle military radios into Havana—arrogant. "I try and stay out of the way of things I don't understand," he says at one point. In other words, he sticks his neck out for nobody. If that line sounds familiar, it's deliberate because the problems of two little people still amount to a hill of beans in a crazy, unstable world, be it Havana or Casablanca. The timeline's just moved up a bit in this one. Alan Arkin (always a pleasure) slots himself into the role of Col. Renault, thinking he knows Jack...but, he "knows Jack." There's also good work done by Tomas Milian as a Batista loyalist and particularly by Daniel Davis. Director Mark Rydell has an amusing turn as mobster Meyer Lansky. Even Richard Farnsworth is in this.
The Firm (1993) John Grisham's break-out best-seller is a cautionary tale about a an upwardly mobile first year lawyer (Tom Cruise), who gets hung up in his "to-die-for" position at a prominent law firm when he has to choose between the job and ethics. But, with the added incentive that his law partners may have him killed if he decides to "do the right thing."
Sabrina (1995) Remake of the 1954 Billy Wilder film (itself broadly based on a Samuel Taylor play "Sabrina Fair") and one of those instances where one of the things wrong with the original could be corrected in the remake. As anyone who's seen Wilder's Sabrina knows, Humphrey Bogart was just the wrong age to be the eventual love interest to Audrey Hepburn. Pollack's Sabrina corrects that by casting the younger and hunkier Harrison Ford as the cold-fish business whiz who sweeps the younger daughter (Julia Ormond) of the family chauffeur (John Wood) away from an irresistible younger brother (Greg Kinnear) who is already betrothed in a mutually beneficial business-marriage (to Lauren Holly).
Random Hearts (1999) He's a D.C. Internal Affairs Sergeant. She's a New Hampshire Congressman running for re-election. What do they have in common? Both of their spouses are cheating on them, but they only find out when the plane the cheating couple were taking to Miami ends up nose-first in the Potomac. Both Sergeant William "Dutch" Van Den Broeck (Harrison Ford) and Kay Chandler (Kristin Scott Thomas) both get the double-whammy that their spouses are dead and that each lied to them about their destination plans. And Van Den Broeck, being a detective, just can't seem to let go of the story discrepancies and ultimately discovers that his wife (Susanna Thompson) and Chandler's husband (Peter Coyote) were having an affair. Once he discovers that, he starts bugging Chandler for any information she might have had about if she knew about it (short answer that he doesn't seem to "get": she didn't). One can make a case that Ford's character is so dogged he could be considered quilty of harassment, and that, although the two do indeed have a lot in common, they're the least likely pair, then, to fall in love and have an affair.
The Interpreter (2005) After years of designing films for how they'd look on pan-sand-scan broadcasts of television, Pollack aggressively embraced the wide-screen format (that had come back into fashion with wide-screen TV's, DVD letter-boxing and acceptance of the originally intended aspect ratio) to make this film set in the United Nations amidst a cowardly new world of terrorism. Nicole Kidman plays Silvia Broome, a UN interpreter from the South African country of Matobo, now being run by a rebel leader turned autocratic dictator. His regime has become involved with ethnic cleansing, the elimination of all political rivals (resulting in the deaths of Broome's entire family) and the General assembly is debating indicting the leader for war crimes. The country's head, Zuwanie (played by the great Earl Cameron), is traveling to the UN to plead his case and the Secret Service is charged with his protection. One of the investigators is Tobin Keller (Sean Penn), who zeroes in on Broome as a person of interest because of her family and past history with Zuwanie's foes. Sure enough, rumblings of an assassination attempt on Zuwanie start to become known and, somehow, Broome is awfully close to some suspicious incidents. It's an above average thriller with some great location work—they were allowed to shoot in the U.N., the first time for a fiction film—and Pollack with a wide-screen to work with is far more artful than before.
Sketches of Frank Gehry (2005) "That is so stupid-looking, it's great!" Frank Gehry chuckles at a cardboard cut-out of a building that he is in the process of designing. It starts as a squiggle, a rat's nest of charcoal lines. And then the modelling starts—cardboard, wood, wire, plastic—and the changes start with all the nuanced little details. The discussion of materials, the physics of the thing, the practicality of it—will it fall down, will it leak—and the aesthetics of it in how the form reflects function. And the light. Does it use light inside and does it reflect light and life outside? Where does the plumbing go? Pollack follows Gehry around his work-spaces, the workshop and a construction site and just talks about the process and the individual feelings he goes through while he's designing—the clearing off of the desk, the fear, the procrastination, the spark. Then the process of changing it for however long it takes. Years, at least. Gehry says he can't look at a building of his for at least a year to appreciate it. Then, he might find some objectivity. Maybe. Made for PBS' "American Masters" series, it's Pollack's last film and a fascinating look at a guy who just has fun doing what he likes to do and seeing how he can stretch it.
"Look at the influence it has, look at the economics it commands, look at the preoccupation in all cultures of the world, look at its power to spread ideas, look at it as a political tool, look at it as entertainment, no matter what point of view you look at it from it would be hard, other than the Internet, let's say, to find something that's changed and affected the world strongly. I mean, certainly it's the single biggest event, I think, in terms of popular entertainment, or art even, if you say that, of the 20th Century. It's been film. It's the 20th Century's real art form."
* The truth is Johnson died in 1900 (after a subsequent stint in the Cavalry and serving as both a deputy sheriff and town marshal in Montana) at the estimated age of 76 in a Santa Monica rest-home (not unlike Jack Crabbe in the earlier Little Big Man) and buried in a veterans' cemetery. After the movie came out, a campaign by students led to Johnson's disinterment and new burial spot located in the "Old Trail Town" in Cody, Wyoming in 1974. One of the pallbearers at the re-burial ceremony was Robert Redford.
I like the way the Italian release of the film makes it look like a violent "spaghetti western"—the title translates as "Red Crow You Will Not Have My Scalp!"
No comments:
Post a Comment